Merino, Lambswool or Cashmere: Which Jumper Should You Buy?

|Ara Ohanian
Merino vs Lambswool vs Cashmere: Which Jumper to Buy
Advertisement

The short version: Buy fine merino for everyday warmth and easy care, lambswool for a sturdier, cosier jumper at a lower price, and cashmere only when it is dense, well-spun and priced like it. The fibre name matters less than its fineness, the yarn and the knit — and the label tells you more than most shoppers read.

November is when most people buy a jumper, and Black Friday is when it is easiest to buy the wrong one. The three names on the tag — merino, lambswool, cashmere — sound like a ladder from good to best. They are not. Each is a different fibre with a different job, and a well-made merino crewneck will almost always outlast a thin, cheap cashmere one. Here is how to choose, what the label is legally required to tell you, and where each one earns its price.

Advertisement

What is the difference between merino, lambswool and cashmere?

All three are animal fibres, but they come from different animals and different parts of the coat. US labelling law, set out in the Wool Products Labeling Act, defines wool as fibre from the fleece of a sheep or lamb, or from the hair of Angora or Cashmere goats, that has not been reclaimed from an earlier product. Within that, the three names mean quite specific things.

Merino is wool from the merino breed of sheep, prized because its fibres are unusually fine. The Woolmark Company, the Australian wool industry’s marketing body, says merino makes up just 1% of the world’s apparel fibre, that it is finer than a human hair, and that it can be softer than cashmere.

Lambswool is wool from a sheep’s first shearing, typically at about seven months, and no more than 50 millimetres long, according to the standard reference definition. It is soft and springy, but it comes from many breeds, so its fineness varies a great deal from one jumper to the next.

Cashmere is not sheep’s wool at all. Under US law it is the fine, dehaired undercoat of the cashmere goat, and it must meet a measurable standard to be sold under that name — which is the one thing about cashmere a shopper can rely on.

Which is softest, and why does some wool itch?

Softness comes down to fibre diameter, measured in microns (millionths of a metre), more than to the animal. Woolmark says the itch and prickle people blame on wool is caused by coarse fibres of any kind, not by wool itself. Fine fibres bend when they touch the skin; thick ones push back.

That is why the grades matter. Creswick Wool, an Australian wool supplier, puts average merino at about 21–22 microns, fine merino at 18.5–19.5, superfine at 15–18.5 and ultrafine below 15. Cashmere, by law in the US, must average no more than 19 microns, with no more than 3% by weight of fibres over 30 microns and a limit on how much the diameters can vary. Lambswool has no single range; Creswick notes it can vary considerably.

Put those numbers side by side and the ladder disappears. A superfine merino at 16 or 17 microns is as fine as, or finer than, plenty of cashmere sitting near the 19-micron limit. A lambswool jumper can feel beautifully soft or noticeably scratchy depending on which flock it came from. If you have sensitive skin, look for the word superfine or a stated micron figure, whatever the fibre.

Which jumper is the warmest?

For the same weight of knit, cashmere usually feels warmest in the hand because its fine, crimped undercoat traps a lot of air for very little weight. But warmth in real wear depends at least as much on how thick and dense the knit is. A chunky lambswool jumper will keep you warmer on a cold walk than a fine-gauge cashmere one that weighs half as much.

The practical rule: judge warmth by picking the jumper up. Weight in the hand and density when you hold it to the light — how much light comes through the stitches — tell you more than the fibre name. A thin, see-through knit in any fibre is a thin, see-through knit.

Which one lasts longest?

Durability belongs to the yarn and the make, not to the fibre on its own. Three things decide it.

One. Fibre length. Longer fibres can be spun with fewer loose ends, so they pill less. Short fibres work their way out of the yarn and ball up on the surface. This is why cheap cashmere pills fast: it is often made from shorter fibres that cost less.

Two. Yarn and ply. Two-ply yarn — two strands twisted together — is stronger and holds its shape better than single-ply. Many of the best jumpers in any fibre are two-ply or more.

Three. Knit density. A tight knit holds its shape at the cuffs and elbows. A loose one stretches and thins where you lean on it.

On those terms, fine merino is often the most practical of the three. It is resilient, recovers its shape well and handles regular wear. Lambswool is hard-wearing and suits heavier, sportier knits. Cashmere is the most delicate of the three and rewards gentle handling; we explained how to read cashmere grades and what actually decides quality, including why “Grade A” on its own means little.

What does the label have to tell you?

More than most people check. Under the Wool Products Labeling Act, a US label must give the percentage by weight of wool, recycled wool and every other fibre making up 5% or more. A product sold simply as “wool” must be 100% wool, apart from up to 5% ornamentation. Terms such as “Super 120s” can only be used if the wool’s average fibre diameter meets the set micron limit, and the label must name the country where the garment was made.

The useful habit is to read the composition before the brand. “Cashmere touch”, “cashmere feel” and “wool blend” are not cashmere or wool. A jumper that is 30% wool and 70% acrylic will behave mostly like acrylic: it pills, holds odour and does not breathe the same way. Our guide to judging a wool coat in the shop uses the same label-first approach for outerwear.

How much should a good jumper cost?

There is no honest single number, but there is a logic. Cashmere costs more because it is only the fine undercoat of the goat, separated from the coarse outer hair; good cashmere at a very low price has usually saved money on fibre length, ply or density. Fine merino is the best value per wear for most people. Lambswool is the budget option that can still be very good, especially from established knitwear mills that specialise in it.

The math compounds over time. A £150 merino jumper worn twice a week through four winters costs well under a pound a wear. A £40 acrylic-blend version that pills and stretches by February has cost you more per wear, and you will be buying it again next year.

Where to spend: vintage and estate knitwear, where old lambswool and Shetland jumpers turn up in excellent condition; independent designers and craft workshops, such as the hand-knit label we covered when Slow Love opened its first shop; accessible-luxury labels that publish their yarn specifications; and a selective handful of mainstream luxury houses for cashmere you will keep for a decade. Skip the mid-tier mass market entirely, where the jumpers that carry a premium name are most often blends with a little wool and a lot of synthetic.

Frequently asked questions

Is merino wool better than cashmere?

For everyday wear, often yes. Fine merino is soft, resilient, easier to care for and usually cheaper, and superfine grades can be as soft as cashmere. Cashmere is lighter and warmer for its weight, and luxurious when it is well made, but it is more delicate and more prone to pilling when it is cheap.

Is lambswool itchy?

It can be, depending on the breed and fibre diameter. Itch comes from coarse fibres, not from wool as such, so a fine lambswool feels soft while a coarser one prickles. If you are sensitive, try it on against bare skin at the wrist or neck before buying, or choose superfine merino.

Why does my cashmere jumper pill so much?

Usually because the fibres are short or the yarn is loosely spun, which is common in cheaper cashmere. Some pilling in the first few wears is normal on any cashmere; constant pilling is a sign of poor fibre. Remove pills gently with a cashmere comb, and wash the jumper by hand or on a wool cycle.

How can I tell if a jumper is real cashmere?

Read the composition label, which must state the fibre content by percentage. Be wary of “cashmere feel” or “cashmere touch”, which describe a finish, not a fibre. A very low price for 100% cashmere is a reason to check the knit density, weight and ply carefully before buying.

Which is best for sensitive skin?

Superfine or ultrafine merino, or good cashmere. What matters is a low fibre diameter. Look for a stated micron figure or the words superfine or extrafine, and avoid blends with coarse wool.

How do I stop moths eating wool and cashmere?

Store jumpers clean and sealed away over summer, and check them through the season. Our guide to protecting wool and cashmere from moths covers what conservators recommend.

What this means for you

Stop treating the three fibres as a ranking. Choose merino for the jumper you will wear most, lambswool for a warm, sturdy knit at a lower price, and cashmere only when the knit is dense, the yarn is two-ply and the price makes sense for both. Read the composition label before the brand, pick the jumper up and hold it to the light, and buy one good one rather than three you will replace next winter.

The next move is yours.

Sources: Wool Products Labeling Act (US Federal Trade Commission) · Cashmere and Camel Hair Manufacturers Institute, legal definition of cashmere · The Woolmark Company on soft merino · Creswick Wool on microns · Lambswool definition

Advertisement