The short version: Most Black Friday discounts are not the lowest price of the year — Which? found every one of 175 deals it tracked in 2024 was the same price or cheaper in the six months around the sale. With clothes, the real test is the price history, the “was” price and the garment itself, not the percentage on the banner.
Black Friday falls on 27 November this year, and the emails have already started. For anyone buying clothes — a coat they have wanted since October, a bag from a label they trust, cashmere for a gift — the question is simple: is this discount real, and is the thing worth having at any price? The answer comes in two parts. One is legal and mechanical: what a shop is allowed to call a “was” price, and how to check it. The other is about the garment, and no discount can fix a bad one.
This guide covers both, with the rules in the EU, the UK and the US, the evidence on how often Black Friday prices are actually the best of the year, and a short routine for checking a fashion deal before you pay.
Are Black Friday deals actually cheaper?
Usually not, according to the most thorough independent tracking available. The UK consumer group Which? follows the prices of popular products for six months before and after Black Friday each year. In its most recent study, of 175 deals from major retailers in the 2024 sales, 100% were the same price or cheaper at some point in the six months either side of the day, Which? reported in November 2025. Inside the wider sales window, from 15 November to 12 December 2024, 42% were cheaper at least once.
The year before, Which? tracked 208 products across eight retailers, including Amazon, Argos, Boots and John Lewis, and found only five were at their lowest price on Black Friday itself. Ele Clark, its retail editor, put the conclusion plainly: “you don't need to feel pressured to splash out on Black Friday”.
It is worth being honest about the limits of that evidence: Which? tracks tech, home and personal-care products, not clothing, and no comparable independent study tracks fashion prices item by item. But the mechanics are the same in every category — the urgency, the countdown clocks, the reference prices — and clothing has one extra twist. Fashion runs on seasons, so the same coat that is “30% off” on 27 November is often marked down again in the January sale, when shops need the space for spring.
What counts as a genuine “was” price?
A genuine “was” price is one the shop actually charged, for a real period, before the cut — and in the EU that is now a legal definition, not a courtesy. The three markets most Faz readers shop in handle it differently.
In the EU: the lowest price of the last 30 days
Since the Omnibus Directive’s changes to EU price rules took effect, Article 6a of the Price Indication Directive (98/6/EC) requires any announced price reduction to show the “prior price”: the lowest price the trader applied during a period of at least 30 days before the reduction. The rule exists to stop the oldest trick in retail — raising a price for a week so that it can be “cut” for the sale.
On 26 September 2024, the Court of Justice of the European Union went further, in a case referred by the Düsseldorf Regional Court. It held that a percentage discount, or any promotional claim about the saving, must be calculated from that 30-day lowest price — not merely displayed next to it. So in an EU shop, “−40%” has to mean 40% below the cheapest price that item sold at in the previous month.
In the UK: misleading prices now carry heavy fines
Britain does not apply the EU’s 30-day formula. What it now has is enforcement. Since 6 April 2025, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act has let the Competition and Markets Authority decide for itself that a business has broken consumer law — including through misleading pricing — and fine it up to 10% of global annual turnover, without going to court first. A fake reference price was always unlawful in the UK; it is now expensive.
In the US: “openly and actively offered for sale”
American rules are older and looser. The Federal Trade Commission’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing (16 CFR Part 233) say a former price is a fair comparison only if the item was “openly and actively offered for sale” for a reasonably substantial period, in good faith. A price set briefly just so it can be cut makes the bargain false, in the FTC’s own words. Comparisons with a “manufacturer’s suggested retail price” are only fair if that price is actually charged by the principal shops in the area — not just quoted on a swing tag.
The practical difference matters. In the EU, the label has to do some of the work for you. In the US, and to a lesser extent the UK, you have to do it yourself.
How do you check a fashion deal before you buy?
You check three things in order: the price history, the reference price, and the garment. It takes about five minutes, and it is the five minutes that separates a good buy from a well-marketed one.
One. Look up the price history. Price trackers such as PriceSpy, Pricerunner and CamelCamelCamel (Amazon only) are the tools Which? recommends. Their fashion coverage is patchier than for electronics, so for clothing, the brand’s own past sale periods are often the better guide: if a label marked the same coat down in last January’s sale, it will very likely do so again.
Two. Question the reference price. If you are shopping in the EU, the struck-through figure should be the lowest price of the last 30 days; if it looks higher than what you saw in October, screenshot it. In the UK and US, ask whether that price was ever the real selling price. “RRP” and “compare at” are the weakest reference points of all — Which? found only 55% of consumers it surveyed knew what RRP even meant.
Three. Judge the garment as if it were full price. Read the composition label, check the seams and the lining, and ask whether you would want this at the original price. If the answer is no, the discount is selling you the percentage, not the piece.
Four. Compare across shops, not just across dates. Multi-brand retailers often carry the same designer pieces at different prices. A “special offer” on one site can be the normal price on another.
Five. Check the returns policy before the checkout page. Some retailers shorten return windows or make sale items final. A bargain you cannot return is a bigger risk on clothes than on almost anything else, because fit is never guaranteed online.
Which brands discount, and which don’t?
The brands most worth buying are often the ones that barely discount at all — and that is a signal, not an inconvenience. Labels that sell mostly at full price usually make smaller runs, plan production more carefully and carry less excess stock, which is exactly why they have little to clear.
At the other end, a brand that is permanently on sale has usually priced its full-price tag to absorb the discount. Michael Kors, owned by Capri Holdings, has been deliberately cutting the number of days it runs promotions to rebuild its pricing, as we covered in our report on Jimmy Choo’s sales and Michael Kors’s discount cuts. When a brand has trained its customers to wait for the sale, the full price stops meaning anything — and so does the “saving”.
This is where the four places Faz recommends shopping sort themselves out quickly. With independent designers and craft workshops, a Black Friday cut is usually small and on last season’s stock — and a small label that makes to order has little excess to clear. With accessible-luxury brands such as Toteme, Polène or Demellier, look at the brand’s own sale history before trusting any banner: a label that rarely discounts is telling you its full price is the real one. Selective mainstream luxury is the hardest place to find a genuine discount, which is part of why luxury prices keep rising, and what the price is paying for. Vintage and estate pieces carry no “was” price to fake in the first place.
Skip the mid-tier mass market entirely on Black Friday. It is the segment where “up to 70% off” is most often a pricing strategy rather than a sale, and where the garment at 70% off is most often the one you will replace next winter.
Is secondhand a better Black Friday buy?
For designer pieces, often yes — because the price on a resale platform is set by the market, not by a marketing calendar. A bag or coat that has already been through one owner has found its real value, and that value does not reset every November.
The usual cautions apply with more force during a rush. Authentication matters more when sellers are busy and buyers are hurried; our step-by-step guide to checking a designer bag before buying secondhand covers the hardware, stitching and paperwork to look at. And if the purchase is a present, there is nothing second-rate about a well-chosen pre-owned piece — the cashmere or the leather does not know it had a previous owner.
Frequently asked questions
When is Black Friday this year?
Black Friday is on Friday 27 November, the day after US Thanksgiving, and Cyber Monday follows on 30 November. Many retailers now run their promotions for most of November, so the day itself is less of a deadline than the marketing suggests.
Is it better to wait for the January sales for clothes?
Often, for seasonal pieces. Winter coats, knitwear and boots are the stock shops most need to clear after Christmas, and Which?’s tracking found prices were cheaper or the same after the sales period in 68% of cases for the products it followed. The trade-off is choice: popular sizes in the best pieces sell through first.
What does “up to 70% off” actually mean?
It means at least one item is 70% off. Most will not be. The headline figure is a ceiling, not an average, and it tells you nothing about the items you actually want.
Is it legal for a shop to raise a price before Black Friday and then cut it?
In the EU, a shop cannot use that inflated price as its reference: the “was” price must be the lowest of the previous 30 days. In the US, the FTC treats a former price set briefly just to be cut as deceptive. In the UK, misleading price claims break consumer law, and the CMA can now fine businesses directly.
Are designer discounts on Black Friday a sign that a brand is in trouble?
Not necessarily, but a sudden, deep sale from a brand that never used to discount is worth noticing. It can mean excess stock, a cash squeeze or a change of owner — all of which can affect after-sales service, repairs and the brand’s future value on the resale market.
Where this leaves you
Black Friday rewards the buyer who arrives with a list and penalises the one who arrives with a mood. Decide what you need before the emails decide for you, check the price history and the reference price, and judge the garment as if it cost full price. If it passes all three, buy it with a clear conscience. If it only passes the first two, the discount is the product.
The next move is yours.
Sources: Which? — How to check if a Black Friday deal is real · Which? Black Friday price study · FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing (16 CFR Part 233) · Baker McKenzie on the CJEU’s 30-day price ruling · CMS on the CMA’s DMCC Act powers